Recently, at Web Directions this year John Allsopp revisted a classic piece of web writing, "A Dao of web design", 11 years since writing it. The presentation stood out as a passionate defence of the things that made the web great including it's universality and openess.
One point he made was a rebuttal to a comment that the "problem" with the web was one of control. This was becoming the defence for why the mobile app model was the future but it's been raised before - that the failings of the web were its lack of control, its slow speed of evolution and its difficulty.
Full disclosure: I'm a web guy. I come down on this argument the same way as John. The web has been 95% of my career thus far, has allowed me to travel the world, speak, write and have a stack of "firsts" that I am very proud of working on.
Having seen the news that Internet Explorer has dropped below 50% browser share for the first time in over a decade I am insanely happy because it proves the point. The web doesn't need curators or controllers, it needs champions. Internet explorer - and specifically IE6 has been the dominant controller of the web for nearly a decade.
But we don't need control, we need champions. Mozilla and Web Kit and Opera were our champions; but so too was the entire web community. By galvanising around web standards we made the case that control wasn't sufficient for innovation or even good implementation.
As the desktop browser champions matured, those of us in the community endorsed the browsers as being "mainstream friendly enough" so we installed firefox or chrome on every machine we could possibly "infect" with a decent, modern, secure browser. That's assuming we didn't just tell the person in question to go buy a Mac (so we could minimise the family and friends tech support calls). So momentum built...
When Nokia originally chose Opera and Mozilla as the core of their mobile web browser and Apple and Android chose webkit they endorsed the open mobile web - with all the consistency issues and difficulty that meant - yet the web browser is still the most used "app" on a mobile phone (outside of the phone and sms functions) and is the fuel of most of the web's current growth. So momentum built...
When the big web properties said "no more IE6" and meant it, license was given to every web developer and designer on the planet to say to their clients they weren't going to support it any more - because just about every client uses at least one of Facebook, Twitter or Google at some point. So momentum built...
Now Microsoft - who famously "embraced and extended" the web and produced IE5 & 6, can't even keep up with the innovation occuring due to the multitude of champions simply pushing the web further, day by day and month by month. With IE10 they will have just about caught up to the bar that has been set by Mozilla and Web Kit - after a decade of almost no innovation - controlling the web by fiat.
And so the champions have prevailed - in an unruly, largely disorganised, bickering, chattering, tweeting mass - but still they have prevailed. In the same way that science, when exposed to the transparency of the scientific method consistently brings new discoveries and innovation.
The position we have attained over the last 18 months and have hit now with this milestone is really a restarting of the process begun in the 90s. Again we see rampant innovation throughout the web - which has been languishing for a long period of time. This is why developers and designers are excited about their craft again after years of just about going nowhere.
But the new front in this war is the Mobile App - with its fallacy of control - and it should hopefully be merely a speedbump in our history, like the ubiquitous onmouseover="rollover()" of 2000. The web doesn't need curators nor control; all it needs are champions who are prepared to make a statement, choose a path, have their views supported or revised and continue to evolve this amazing platform.
Source for citation: ajfisher.me/2011/11/03/we-are-the-champions-of-the-web.